2006年10月16日

三電影

電話謀殺案
1954年的電影,在家看vcd。頭半段我覺得普通,到破案時,我才驚覺劇情的精妙。對希治閣的第一感很好,喜歡偵探小說的都會喜歡他吧。

穿prada的惡魔
可能聽太多人讚了,反而沒驚喜。當然我也經歷過類似的東東:辦公室一群女人互相撕殺的殘酷、事業家人如何取捨、上位和道德之間的掙扎。只是,或者,我真是過了那年紀了,看完,笑了笑,明白那女主角最後的決定,亦相信,那段日子,只成為回憶的一部份了。

無間道風雲
很多人說馬田史高西斯重拍得好,我卻覺得還是港版好看得多了。新版是缺少了一份人情味,缺少了那份好人、壞人的矛盾,無間道的主題不就是好壞難分嗎?

里安納度的角色,和梁朝偉演的有點不同,很難比;但麥迪文和劉華,就可以比了,別先說我偏心,還是覺得劉華演得好得多,意氣風發之餘,眼神動靜也有脆弱和矛盾的時候,他是想過做好人的,但最後「選擇」了做壞人,但麥迪文呢,似乎由始至終都是心在黑幫,不夠無間是吧。

不過,新不如舊又不等於不值得看,特別是喜歡里安納度的,進場吧,演的很精彩,閃縮的眼神、心虛的語氣、動靜,流暢自然,誰還敢再說他靠靚樣搵食呢?

4 則留言:

匿名 說...

I feel the same for 穿Prada的惡魔 and 無間道風雲!

Sunshine in me

匿名 說...

"dial m for murder" is a joke on traditional detectives. it's message is "a murder would never execued as perfect as planned".

for hitchcock, "vertigo" is my 1st choice. "rope" & "rear window" are interesting. "psycho" & "bird" are classy. go watch it asap la...

for "prada", i have no expectation. actually the mass in hk just c too much meaningless films. once sth got a little bit message, they would praise it to the sky. to me, it is just a mental drug to ease the mental struggle of typical OL. the difficulties in work was just comedy, not realistic and ending turn of the main actress is so optimistic. u c most OL are still traped by fame, success & materials. how come she would be get ride of the lost & claim bakc she own self so easily. by the way, the boss is too human. it is also to be good to those boss rank audience so as to get as much market as possible. then the boss level rank would feel "yes, yes, i'm not so bad indeed. i am just being harsh for difficult hidden reason out of my will." anyway, the script of this film is still pretty good as hollywood standard.

for "departed" i think it is made fairly good, at least quite different fr the HK version. it skipped those big scenes & focused on the long fear of the 2 underlays. not bad in short.

(sorry for postin in english for urging to leave today)

匿名 說...

飛人,舊blog不見了.全鏟了嗎?還是另有link?有冇backup?

匿名 說...

三套我也沒看過...

不過我的好友卻認為 Martin Scorses 拍得不錯, 比港版好.

由於我連港版也未看過, 不能表達意見. ^^